He can name all eleven, in order, and he has never written the list down anywhere, and it has never needed writing down.
He was the one who brought it in. He had been to something, he came back changed, he told the eldership honestly what had happened to him, and over the following year that congregation began to move. None of it was underhand. It was discussed, it was prayed about, it was decided together.
And over the three years after that, eleven people he loved worshipped somewhere else.
Some of them said goodbye properly. Two did not, and he still notices their absence in a particular seat every week even now. One of them was a man he had visited in hospital eleven times.
Nine years later he still cannot decide what he is. On the good days he is a man who was obedient and paid for it. On the other days, at about four in the morning, he is a man who broke a church for an experience he cannot even prove, and there is a running total attached, and the total is eleven.
If you are the one who brought it in, come in and sit down. Not one of those eleven is going to be criticized on this page, and neither are you.
He has been keeping a ledger nobody assigned him
Let us look at what he has actually been doing for nine years, because it is not repentance and it is not accountability.
He has been running a private account in which every departure is a line item and he is the debtor. Nobody in that eldership ever handed him that account. No leaver ever sent him a bill. He opened it himself, at about four in the morning, some time in the first year, and it has been accruing ever since.
And the account has a fault in its arithmetic: it credits him with an authority over other people's decisions that he never had and would not want. Eleven adults weighed something and chose. Treating their choices as his output is not humility. It is a quiet overestimate of himself, worn as guilt.
You are not the debtor here. Nothing eleven adults decided in their own homes has ever been a charge against you. I am not saying that to let a man off. Scripture says neither is he that planteth any thing, neither he that watereth; but God that giveth the increase (1 Corinthians 3:7), which takes the whole outcome out of the hands of the man who did the work, and the Holy Spirit is the one who makes that hold at four in the morning.
The outcome was never on the planter
Here is the part that turned this for me, and it puts nothing on anybody who left.
Read how far Paul goes in taking the result off the workers, because he goes further than sounds polite.
So then neither is he that planteth any thing, neither he that watereth; but God that giveth the increase.1 Corinthians 3:7
Neither is he anything. Not a lesser factor, not a junior partner. The men who did the actual work are removed from the accounting of the result entirely, and this is said by one of the men being removed.
That is not a way of dodging responsibility for what a person does. It is a statement about who owns outcomes, and the answer is not the person who planted, however honestly and however much it cost him.
You did the planting and He owns the increase, and Scripture removes the worker from the reckoning by name. That is written into the verse itself, and it is the Holy Spirit who brings it to a man with a list of eleven.
Not one of the eleven is being judged here
Something must be said very plainly, or this becomes a page that quietly convicts the people who left in order to acquit the man who stayed.
They were not disloyal. Each of them weighed something serious, in their own house, with their own conscience, and went where they believed they should go, and several of them said goodbye with tears and meant every word. Two of them found it too hard to say goodbye at all, which is a fact about how much it cost them and not about how little they cared.
And you were not wrong to say what happened to you.
This was real and it cost you. You can hold both without deciding which of you was wrong. Scripture says if it be possible, as much as lieth in you, live peaceably with all men (Romans 12:18), where the qualifier concedes that some of it never lay with you at all, and it is the Holy Spirit, and not a settled verdict on eleven people, who lets you keep them and keep the truth.
And if these nine years have cost more than the people in that hall know, if sleep has gone, if four in the morning has become the worst hour of your day, please talk to somebody real: your doctor, a counselor, a crisis line, and the emergency services if there is danger to anybody tonight. That is not a detour around God. It is one of the ways He keeps people, and a man in ministry is not exempt from needing it.
So here is the turn, and it is not a promise that any of the eleven come back.
This was real and it cost you. You can hold both without deciding which of you was wrong. Scripture says neither is he that planteth any thing, but God that giveth the increase (1 Corinthians 3:7), where the outcome is removed from the worker by name, and it is the Holy Spirit, not a ruling on who was right, who lets you grieve those eleven without owing for them.
I cannot tell you what God does with that church, or with them, or with the seats. Nobody honest would. What I can tell you is that grief and guilt have been fused in you for nine years and they are two different things, and only one of them was ever yours.
Declare this over yourself
Say these out loud, in your own voice. You are in Christ and Christ is in you, and the standing under these words is His rather than your own. You speak under His will and not yours, and what God does next, and when, is His to decide, however He answers.
- Ledger of eleven names I have kept for nine years, you are grief I never had anywhere to put and you are not a bill made out to me. First Corinthians 3 says neither the one who plants nor the one who waters is anything, but God gives the increase, so the outcome was removed from the worker by name, and the Holy Spirit has been in that building the whole nine years. In the name of Jesus I close the account.
- Four in the morning verdict that I broke a church, you are not what God says about me and you are not sitting in this hall tomorrow. Romans 12 says live peaceably as much as lieth in you, which concedes that eleven adult decisions were never in my hands, and His Spirit keeps me steady without a ruling on anybody. I am grieving them instead of paying for them.
- Father, You gave the increase, and First Corinthians 3 says neither the one who plants nor the one who waters is anything. I thank You that those eleven are still Yours and still mine, and that what happened to me was real and worth telling that eldership, and Your Spirit has stayed with me through every year of it. This was real and it cost me, and I can hold both without deciding which of us was wrong.
1 Corinthians 3:7
This message is free, and always will be. There is nothing to unlock, nothing to subscribe to, and nothing you owe for having received it.
